2023 – Dakota Perock
2022 – Tre Baumgart
2021 – Mitchel Mergener, Matt Frank
2020 – Brett Buboltz, Trevor Ramseier, Bryan Vande Hei
2019 – Ryan Waldschmidt, Tommy Byrne
2018 – Nick Pierre
2017 – Travis Mason, Dakota Perock, Josh Teske
2016 – Brandon Byrne
2015 – Matt Freeman, Ryan Waldschmidt
2014 – Jordan Koch
2013 – Drew Nowak
2012 – Brett Spaeth
2011 – Jeff Behrendt
2010 – Darin Black
2009 – Bob Van Rens
2008 – Corey Haese, Jeremy Rotzenberg
2007 – Chris Brault, Mark Leidel
2006 – Chad Thomson
2005 – Phil Corbin
2004 – Matt Danen
2003 -Tim Jolly, Pete VanSistine
2002 – Todd LeMieux
2001 – Pete Lamers
2000 – Dan “Dish” Disher
1999 – Jerry Bos, Jason Schweitzer
1998 – Luke Dantoin, Lance Koltz, Bryan Vande Hei
1997 – Tom Aerts, Mike Gentile
1996 – Mike Hanrahan, Steve “Woody” Allen
1995 – Jim Rottier, John DeRuyter
1994 – Stan Scheffen
1993 – Andy Stuckart
1992 – Al “Ferris” Buehler
1991 – John Danen
1990 – Herb Foote, Dave Heuvelmans
1989 – Pete Thomson
1988 – Paul “Whitey” McDonough
1987 – Joe Van Deurzen
1986 – Pete Bloemer
1985 – No MVP Awarded
1984 – No MVP Awarded